Car Breakdowns: Is It Worth Repairing or Should You Call It Quits?

Anyone who owns an automobile has likely faced the typical dilemma: when your vehicle breaks down, should you bite the bullet and pay for costly repairs, or should you bid farewell and take it to the salvage yard? It’s a decision that can be as complex as the inner workings of a combustion engine. With factors like repair costs, the car’s actual cash value, and potential salvage yard profits to consider, the answer isn’t always clear-cut.

In this blog post, we’ll explore the various factors you should take into account to make the best decision for you and your trusty four-wheeled companion.

Call 317-218-7133 to Get Paid Instant Cash at Our Auto Salvage Yard in Indianapolis Indiana
Call 317-218-7133 to Get Paid Instant Cash at Our Auto Salvage Yard in Indianapolis Indiana

The Most Expensive Car Brands to Repair in the U.S.

Owning a car is already a significant expense, but some car owners have to dig deeper into their pockets when it comes to repairs. High end cars are notorious for their luxurious and high-performing features, but they also come with a high price tag for maintenance and repairs, especially engines. According to recent studies, some of the top car brands that make the most expensive cars to repair in the United States include Porsche, BMW, Audi, Mercedes-Benz, and Tesla. The cost of labor, parts, and specialized expertise needed for these cars can quickly add up, leaving car owners with a hefty bill to pay. Despite the potential financial burden of owning one of these expensive cars, many continue to choose them for their exceptional quality and status symbol.

To Repair or Scrap? That is the Car Breakdown Question

Rising Car Repair Costs

The first and most obvious factor to consider is the cost of repairs. Depending on the issue, fixing a broken car can range anywhere from a few hundred dollars to several thousand. If the repair costs are relatively low and won’t break your budget, it may be worth repairing your vehicle. However, if the price tag for repairs is steep and surpasses the actual market value of your car, it may be time to consider other options.

Actual Cash Value (ACV)

The actual cash value (ACV) of a vehicle is the current market value of the car at the time of breakdown. It takes into account factors like age, mileage, and condition. If your car’s ACV is low and close to or less than the cost of repairs, it may not be worth fixing. In this case, you may be better off selling your car to a salvage yard and using that money towards purchasing a new vehicle.

Salvage Yard Profits

Speaking of salvage yards, they can be an excellent option for vehicles beyond repair. Auto scrappers purchase junk cars for their parts or scrap metal, so they may offer you more money for your broken-down car than its ACV. However, it’s essential to do your research and compare prices from various salvage yards before making a decision. Some may have better deals or offers, so it pays to shop around.

Other Factors to Consider

Besides repair costs, ACV, and potential profits from a salvage yard sale, there are other factors to consider when deciding whether to repair or scrap your car. For instance, how frequently has your vehicle broken down in the past? If it’s a recurring issue and you’ve already sunk a considerable amount of money into repairs, it may be time to cut your losses and move on. Additionally, think about if the breakdown will impact your daily life significantly. Are you reliant on your vehicle for transportation to work or other essential activities? If so, repairing it may be the best option.


In the end, the decision to repair or scrap your car depends on various factors and ultimately comes down to what is best for you. Take into account repair costs, actual cash value, salvage yard profits, and other personal considerations when making this decision. Remember that a mechanic can give you an estimate of repair costs, and salvage yards are always an option if repairs aren’t feasible. Whatever you decide, know that there is no right or wrong answer, and it’s a choice that only you can make.  So next time your car breaks down, think carefully about what makes the most sense for your situation before making a decision.

Looking for a trustworthy auto salvage yard in Indiana that will provide the best possible price for your totaled vehicle? Contact Benjamin’s Junk Cars at 317-218-7133 to learn how it works when it comes to selling a junk car for cash in Indianapolis. We provide free junk car towing, so all you need to do is call!

Related Posts:

The Top 3 Most Expensive Auto Repairs
Junk Car Parts With the Highest Scrap Value
How to Deal With an Expensive Car Repair You Can’t Afford